Heretic doesn't play out with the typical levels of jump scares and macabre we're used to from horror films these days -- rather it's a battle of wits in which the characters contemplate belief, religion, and faith... oh, and an adult man is terrorizing two young women as they're held captive in his house, which becomes a maze of puzzles related to his disdain for their faith. Hugh Grant is rather terrifying as Mr. Reed here, but he's clearly having such a delightful time in the character's skin. He's as threatening as you can imagine a mysterious man in his 60s alone in a large house but also has plenty of outlandish and hilarious dialogue. Some viewers simply looking for an intellectual dark comedy could most definitely find satisfaction in watching Heretic. You also genuinely care about our two protagonists. Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East both bring cleverness to the film, a willingness to challenge their captor, and not break down and quit. Thatcher brings a rebellious sense of mystery to Sister Barnes, while Chloe East is heartfelt and capable as Sister Paxton.
Though Heretic takes some time for the uniqueness and thrills to set in, it stands out from other recent horror films thanks to its restraint on its scares, as well as its smart screenplay and chilling villain. The three performances are integral and lift up the film's shocking fun, and may even make you think about some big ideas all while you're enjoying this dark ride.
3.5/5
Review by: Gal Balaban